The Press Hawkins Construction

10 years of Press Cup History

16 May 2011

WHY “THE PRESS CUP” AND HOW?
After three or four years of the same competition in the Christchurch Metropolitan Under 18 Section One grade the five secondary schools in competition had dominated and become somewhat disenchanted with having to play each other four or even five times in a season. It was considered that broadening the competition to include teams within what had become the Crusaders region would provide additional competition and a refreshing approach to schools’ rugby where teams would travel and have an experience greater than just their weekly rugby match.  The concept was to have the five Christchurch (Canterbury) schools compete against a team from each of the other six provincial unions that formed the Crusaders’ region.  As Nelson was the second largest province they would have 2 teams, and West Coast and Buller were rolled into one because of the population base.

The concept gained approval in October 2000 and was quickly put in place once the schools identified as being likely parties to the idea had agreed to participate.  That was instantaneous and the competition proposal and regulations were put to the schools and accepted in November 2000. The final ingredients of The Press Cup were confirmed in April 2001 and the first games were played at the start of the second school term 2001.

The concept was also accepted by the Crusaders Franchise Board of Directors who considered it was a valuable development programme for the talented players coming through the schools’ system.

The 12 schools that participated in the inaugural year were: Aranui H S, Christchurch B H S, Christ’s College, St Andrew’s College, St Bede’s College, Shirley B H S (Canterbury), Nelson Boys’ College, Waimea College (Nelson), Ashburton College, (Mid Canterbury), Timaru B H S (South Canterbury), Marlborough Boys’ College (Marlborough) and a combined team from West Coast High Schools (West Coast and Buller). Aranui H S was a new entry into secondary schools First XV rugby competition, but had a strong team of mainly rugby league players but wished to develop rugby union in their school.

FUNDING
The then Marketing Manager of the Canterbury Rugby Union took a proposal to prospective sponsors which was taken up by The Press newspaper, appropriately, as they were the one medium to cover the whole of the region from Timaru to Nelson.

The Press sponsorship included a cash sum in addition to naming rights. That sum was added to by the Crusaders’ Board and the funding was distributed on a travel based system according to the draw. The initial level of cash sponsorship has remained static throughout the first nine years.

Remaining funding was the responsibility of each school participating. Mainland Sport, a gaming machine trust established initially to manage the gaming machines at the Holy Grail Hotel in Christchurch for the benefit of rugby union, primarily, in the Crusaders region was a source schools were encouraged to apply to for annual grants to meet the majority of their travel and accommodation costs. This has now become a fixed sum also which is distributed on the travel basis. Other fund raising was necessary with schools taking different views on how the extra funding was to be found – some by additional fund raising activities and some by a flat levy on the players (families). 

THE DRAW
Many of the participating schools had annual fixtures against each other on traditional dates as well as fixtures against other schools outside the region. The home games were to be reversed in successive years. A number of games were changed from week days to Saturdays, a move which met the approval of schools’ principals.

Every endeavour has been made to meet the requests for certain games to be played on certain dates. Up to 15 game requests in any one season have been fitted into draws. This requires a lengthy process to piece the puzzle together and produce a draw which is fair to all the teams. It was thought that once a suitable draw had been found it could be reversed (home and away) the following year but that has not been the case. The numbers changed when West Coast could not field a team in 2003, but were able to be reinstated in 2004 and 2005, but were out again in 2006 and back in from 2007 to the present time. Then Ashburton College faced difficulties in 2004 and a special agreement for “loan players” was reached to ensure the team continued throughout the season, but after getting through 2005 had to withdraw in 2006 and have not yet returned.

At the end of 2004 schools wishing to become a part of the competition raised questions as to what they had to do to be included. At that time it was agreed by all participants that challenge regulations be formulated. These were agreed and three schools (Burnside H S, Roncalli College and St Thomas of Canterbury College) sought a place for 2005 – Burnside H S was successful in its two matches in a pre 2005 tournament and duly took its place in The Press Cup.

The following year, 2006, Aranui H S withdrew from the competition (cost being the major factor) as did Ashburton and as St Thomas’ College was still keen to enter it duly took up one of the two vacant spots. Roncalli College did not apply again but Lincoln High School expressed interest and having been a successful team in its grade competition in 2005 was accepted as the second replacement team.

Those have been the only additions and withdrawals from the competition although there have been queries from Motueka H S and Nayland College in the Nelson province and in recent times Rangiora H S has expressed interest.

The challenge regulations provide that a team must qualify by winning its school competition or being the highest placed school team in its provincial age grade competitions and play off against the bottom placed team (if there is more than one as is the case in Canterbury and Nelson) and the game must be played three weeks prior to the succeeding season in which the challenging teams have qualified as a challenger, i.e. to ensure the teams play with the players who make up the team for the challenge will, in fact, be the players who will be available for the current season, not those Year 13 players who have left school.

The initial draw had to be reviewed for a number of reasons after 2004 and a new draw was constructed for 2005.

For the 2011 season a new format has been estbalished.The preliminary round sees teams split in two sections; The Northern teams comprising of St Thomas's, Waimea College, St Bede's College, Nelson College, Rangiora High School, St Andrew's College, Marlborough Boy's College and Nayland College.The Southern Section including Shirley Boy's High School, Timaru Boy's High School, Roncalli College, Christchurch Boy's High School, Ashburton College, Lincoln High School, Christ's College and Burnside High School.

THE MATCHES
The inaugural competition was a round robin with the first and second placed teams playing off for The Press Cup. That was changed in 2002 when all teams were given the opportunity to play for a trophy. A round robin was played and the teams were split into groups of four to play semi finals and the final for The Press Cup (1st to 4th placed teams), The Press Plate (5th to 8th placed teams) and The Press Bowl (9th to 12th placed teams).
From 2011 the first round of the competition will consist of a round-robin of 7 games for each section. The top four placed teams on competition points, from each section will go through to the Top 8 (Section 1). The bottom four placed teams from each section will go through to the Bottom 8 (Section 2).

In the second round, each team will play the other four teams they are yet to play. Results of games played between teams from the same section in the first round will carry through to the second round, i.e. their fixtures will not be repeated. Results will include competition standing points and points for and against.

DISCIPLINARY MATTERS
The on field discipline has been of the high standard expected in secondary schools rugby with only three orderings off having occurred in the first 8 years and one of those was for persistent infringement after a team warning. The other two were proven to be of foul play of a minor nature.

The sin bin has been used relatively little for foul play, most offences being since professional fouls have become punishable by use of the sin bin.

 HAKAS
A feature of secondary schools’ rugby is the team haka.   These have generally been performed with passion and within guidelines, but there have been occasions when the protocols have been broken and on one occasion sanctions were invoked.

PROMOTION
Probably the greatest promotion of The Press Cup has been CTV (Canterbury’s local television channel) who saw the value in the strong following the competition had received in its initial year and agreed (via Canterbury R F U, at a cost) to film one match in Christchurch each week of the competition for replay on Sunday (and sometimes during the week). It has remained a popular programme for CTV viewers. Every endeavour is made to film each team at least once. CTV travelled to Blenheim in 2006 and Nelson in 2007 to film The Press Cup final.

A weekly report of matches played and items of interest has also been published by email from the Canterbury R F U office since the tournament’s inception. This has extended to a very wide database.

PLAYER DEVELOPMENT - HONOURS
There has been an incredible abundance of talented players who have played in The Press Cup which is clearly demonstrated by the following list of achievements:

 All Blacks
The honour of the first All Black to be selected after having played his secondary school rugby in The Press Cup rests with James Ryan (Christ’s College) whose selection came in 2005. Others who have achieved the highest honour are:

Adam Thomson (Christchurch B H S) 2008 – 2009

Ben Franks (Aranui H S) 2008

Isaac Ross (Timaru B H S) 2009

Owen Franks (Christchurch B H S) 2009.

Honours abound in other national teams. They are:

Junior All Blacks

Stephen Brett (Christchurch B H S) 2007, 2009

Ryan Crotty (Shirley B H S) 2009

Colin Slade (Christchurch B H S) 2009

N Z Maori

Isaac Ross (Timaru B H S) 2008

Stephen Brett (Christchurch B H S) 2008

Tim Bateman (Christchurch B H S) 2008

N Z Divisional / Heartland XV

Aaron Bancroft (Marlborough B C) 2005

Robbie Malneek (Nelson College) 2005

Hamish McKenzie (Timaru B H S) 2006, 2008                      

Jon Dampney (Ashburton College) 2008

Corey Simpson (Shirley B H S) 2008

N Z Sevens

George Naoupu (Christchurch B H S) 2005

Nick Thomson (Christchurch B H S) 2006, 2007

Adam Thomson (Christchurch B H S) 2007

Steven Yates (Christchurch B H S) 2007, 2008

(Footnote: It is significant that in one match on the World Sevens circuit in 2007 the three players above, together with another former Christchurch B H S player, Afeleke Perenise, were on the field at one time).

N Z Under 21

Ben Franks (Aranui H S) 2004, 2005

George Naoupu (Christchuirch B H S) 2004

James Ryan (Christ’s College) 2004

Mikaele Tuu’u (St Andrew’s College) 2004, 2005, 2006

Aaron Bancroft (Marlborough B C) 2005, 2006

Stephen Brett (Christchurch B H S) 2005, 2006

Marcel Cummings-Toone (Shirley B H S) 2005

Brett Mather (Shirley B H S) 2005

Peter Nixon (Christ’s College) 2005

Isaac Ross (Timaru B H S) 2005

Robbie Flynn (Shirley B H S) 2006

Matt Holloway (Christchurch B H S) 2006

Michael Paterson (Christ’s College) 2006

Josh Townsend (Christchurch B H S) 2006

Tim Bateman (Christchurch B H S) 2007

Owen Franks (Christchurch B H S) 2007

Colin Slade (Christchurch B H S) 2007

N Z Under 20

Ash Dixon (Christchurch B H S) 2008

Hugh Reed (Christchurch B H S) 2008

Quentin MacDonald (Marlborough B C) 2008

Ryan Crotty (Shirley B H S) 2008

Luikanasi Manu (Christchurch B H S) 2008

Hamish Cochrane (Marlborough B C) 2009

Elliot Dixon (St Bede’s College) 2009

Alex Ryan (St Bede’s College) 2009

Thomas Taylor (Burnside H S) 2009

N Z Under 19

James Ryan (Christ’s College) 2001, 2002

George Naoupu (Christchurch B H S) 2002

Aaron Bancroft (Marlborough B C) 2003, 2004

Marcel Cummings-Toone (Shirley B H S) 2003

Ben Franks (Aranui H S) 2003

Isaac Ross (Timaru B H S) 2003, 2004

Sam Giddens (Nelson College) 2003

M J Robertson-Tiueti (Marlborough B C) 2003

Adam Thomson (Christchurch B H S) 2003

Henry Johnstone (Timaru B H S) 2004

Josh Keys (Christchurch B H S) 2004

Michael Paterson (Christ’s College) 2004

Mikaele Tuu’u (St Andrew’s College) 2004

Tim Bateman (Christchurch B H S) 2005, 2006

Jonathon Direen (Christchurch B H S) 2005, 2006

Robbie Flynn (Shirley B H S) 2005

Brett Mather (Shirley B H S) 2005

Charles O’Connell (Christ’s College) 2005

Baydon Phillips (Christchurch B H S) 2005

Mason Pomare (Christchurch B H S) 2005, 2006

Nicholas Thomson (Christchurch B H S) 2005

Michael Coman (Waimea College) 2006

John Legge (Christchurch B H S) 2006

Hoani Matenga (Christchurch B H S) 2006

Colin Slade (Christchurch B H S) 2006

Ryan Crotty (Shirley B H S) 2007

Liukanasi Manu (Christchurch B H S) 2007

Quentin MacDonald (Marlborough B C) 2007

Rodney Ah You (Christchurch B H S0 2007

Ash Dixon (Christchurch B H S) 2007

N Z Secondary Schools

Jonathon Poff (St Bede’s College) 2001

Michael Davis (Christ’s College) 2001

George Naoupu (Christchurch B H S) 2001

Aaron Bancroft (Marlborough B C) 2002

Tim Crooks (St Andrew’s College) 2002

Jeremy Manning (Marlborough Boys’ College) 2002

Marcel Cummings-Toone (Shirley B H S 2002

Aaron Bancroft (Marlborough B C) 2003

Jeremy Manning (Marlborough B C0 2003

Todd Nicholas (Marlborough B C) 2003

Michael Paterson (Christs’s College) 2003

Jonathon Direen (Christchurch B H S) 2004

Baydon Phillips (Christchurch B H S) 2004

Michael Coman (Waimea College) 2005

Owen Franks (Christchurch B H S) 2005

Liukanasi Manu (Christchurch B H S) 2005, 2006

Mason Pomare (Christchurch B H S) 2005

Hamish Cochrane (Marlborough B C) 2006

Ryan Crotty (Shirley B H S) 2006

Ash Dixon (Christchurch B H S) 2006

Quentin MacDonald (Marlborough B C) 2006

Tim Perry (St Andrew’s College) 2006

Hugh Reed (Christchurch B H S) 2006

Nick Anneear (Timaru B H S) 2007, 2008

Elliot Dixon (St Bede’s College) 2007

Jason Morgan (St Bede’s College) 2007

Michael Newman (Timaru B H S) 2007

Alex Ryan (St Bede’s College) 2007

James Hadfield (Nelson College) 2008

Rhys Llewellyn (St Bede’s College) 2008

Logan Taylor (St Bede’s College) 2008

N Z Kiwi Rugby League team

Simon Mannering (Nelson College) 2007, 2008, 2009

Setaimata Sa (Shirley B H S) 2008, 2009

With such a large list of players having gained national honours it goes without saying that a great number more have represented their provincial age grade and Air New Zealand, Meads and Lochore Cup teams while others have transferred to other provinces achieve similar honours. That information is not all available to the writer so has been omitted from this summary.

The information that is available is those players who have represented Rugby Super 12 and Super 14 teams, the Crusaders and the Highlanders. They are:

 Crusaders

Steven Yates (Christchurch B H S)

Stephen Brett (Christchurch B H S)

Ben Franks (Aranui H S)

Peter Nixon (Christ’s College)

Michael Paterson (Christ’s College)

Tim Bateman (Christchurch B H S)

Isaac Ross (Timaru B H S)

Liukanasi Manu (Christchurch B H S)

Colin Slade (Christchurch B H S)

Ryan Crotty (Shirley B H S)

Owen Franks (Christchurch B H S)

Jonathon Poff (St Bede’s College)

Highlanders

Aaron Bancroft (Marlborough B C)

Adam Thompson (Christchurch B H S)

George Naoupu (Christchurch B H S)

Sean Romans (St Andrew’s College

Brett Mather (Shirley B H S)

Lucky Mulipola (Nelson College)

A representative feat of note was Jeremy Manning (Marlborough B C) playing for Munster against the All Blacks in November 2008.

TEAMS’ PERFORMANCES

Christchurch BH S won the The Press Cup on the first six occasions (2001 – 2006), Nelson College won in 2007 and St Bede’s College in 2008, 2009 and 2010.

The winners of The Press Plate have been St Bede’s College 2002, 2004, 2005, 2006, Timaru B H S 2003, d St Andrew’s College 2007, 2008 and Marlborough Boys' College 2009, 2010.

The winners of The Press Bowl have been Christ’s College 2002, 2004, Marlborough Boys’ College 2003, West Coast High Schools 2004 (draw with Christ’s College), St Andrew’s College 2005, Lincoln High School 2006, St Thomas’ College 2007, 2010 and Waimea College 2008.

Most points in a season:798 - St Bedes 2010

Most tries in season:126 - St Bedes 2010

Most conversions in a season:75 - St Bedes 2010

Most penalty goals in a season:29 - Marlborough BC 2002

Most dropped goals in a season:5 - STAC 2003    

 

INDIVIDUALS’ PERFORMANCES

Most points in a season:236 - Marty McKenzie(Christ's College) - 2010

Most tries in a season:26 - Marty McKenzie(Christ's College) - 2010

Most conversions in a season:50 - James Lash (Nelson College)-2007

Most penalty goals in a season:29 - Jeremy Manning (Marlborough B C)-2002

Most dropped goals in a season:5 - Chris Lumsden (St Andrew’s College)-2003               

CONCLUSION
There is no doubt the initial objectives have been met and probably exceeded. The Press Cup is the envy of other regions throughout New Zealand in that it is managed by a provincial rugby union, rather than the secondary schools themselves. The Highlanders region this year commenced a regional competition based on The Press Cup model.

With the tenth year coming up in 2010 it may be that it is time to take a good look at what has happened, how times have changed, if they have, and as with other competitions decide whether change is required to maintain and hopefully increase interest and support for what is seen as a high quality secondary schools’ product.

Warren Barberel
Former Rugby Manager
Canterbury
R F U
July 2009

Location

http://www.canterburycommunityrugby.co.nz/main/index.cfm/1,538,3092,0,html

Site by Orbital Ltd